Refreshingly blunt
by Volker Weber
Robert Scoble and Shel Israel visit Amazon for some cheerleading about blogging. Amazon CTO asks tough questions:
Welcome to life at Amazon, we set a very high bar for our own works and we expect anyone that comes to sell us an approach to actually be prepared to really defend their ideas. Just because blogs are cool and everybody is doing them does not automatically mean that we should institutionalize them at Amazon. We have a long history of promoting customers to use their voice about our products and our operations, so if you come to Amazon to tell us our business is going to really suffer if we do not blog, you better be prepared to defend your ideas with very strong arguments and hard evidence.
Apparently Scoble and Israel were not prepared:
I wanted them abandon their fuzzy group hug approach, and counter me with hard arguments why they were right and I was wrong. Instead they appeared shell-shocked that anyone actually had the guts to challenge the golden wonder boys of blogging and not accept their religion instantly. I have been a promoter of weblogging for a long time, so I didn't feel particularly bad to challenge these two authors to tell me why customers would get a better Amazon product ... In my mind they had no solid data-driven answers to these challenges, which I would have expected from two seasoned evangelists. I myself actually knew some of the answers to my questions, but I was surprised to see that these guys were not prepared enough to slap me around with solid answers.
This is a must read for all "Chief Blogging Consultants" out there.
[via Robert]
Comments
Recent comments
Alex Wokurka
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 23:14
Ragnar Schierholz
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 23:02
Volker Weber
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 21:53
Ben Poole
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 21:07
Pieterjan Lansbergen
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 21:03
Jan Tietze
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 20:48
Ben Rose
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 15:14
Ben Rose
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 14:46
Philipp Sury
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 13:40
Sascha Reissner
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 13:28
Ben Rose
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 12:10
Colin Williams
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 09:43
Adalbert Duda
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 09:33
Volker Weber
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 09:28
Jan Tietze
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 08:53
Ben Rose
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 08:14
Volker Weber
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 04:50
Amy Blumenfield
on No surprises at the PhilNote at 01:36
Richard Schwartz
on Peter O'Kelly: I am now a Microsoft employee at 02:49
Hanno Zulla
on Ente Chop Sui at 22:32
Kristof Doffing
on Ich helfe gerne aus der Autokrise at 15:03
Bruce Lill
on IBM is not going to send out a press release at 00:31
Thomas Cloer
on Events of the last few days at 12:38
David M Taylor
on Two screens or one? at 03:27
Henrik Heigl
on Events of the last few days at 18:51
Click here to subscribe
Post a comment