A developer asks: What should the Notes desktop really look like?
by Volker Weber
Are you still using the same desktop workspace in Notes that you were 10 years ago? Truth be told, it is a desktop paradigm that even looks ugly when compared to the Mac Finder interface in 1991. Although there have been attempts a replacement, most of us still use this dog of a UI with 32x32 pixel 16 color icons set into square blocks about 3 times that size. We can even organize these application icons any way we like - as long as we like gray on gray in a grid pattern. We can even have folder tabs to group your little square into families.
Why do we keep using this? Because the alternatives have been worse. Instead of focusing on what desktop users want out of an interface, IBM has for years combined mistaken approaches together into a huge waste of opportunity.
Comments
Bullocks (love that word ;-)) - he want's to integrate everything into the operating system or even worse the folder system - that's so 1990. The bookmarks got way better with Notes 8 however I don't use them and I don't want to use them, because I have my dear workspace.
The workspace still exists because the users asked for it. It's easy to use, that's it.
Anyway you can make it prettier if you want - you linked to the tool few weeks ago. I did it and like it even more now.
I hardly ever agree on anything with Andrew. :-)
Martin, it’s “bollocks” :o)
Would this task be assigned to Ray O, then? He holds right the position now to integrate his legacy directly into the Windows kernel. Uhh - don't mind.
@Martin -Help me understand what you're saying. Bookmarks are fine. In fact they're much better in R8. Oh, but you don't use them. You use a workspace file (as do I) that has remained largely unchanged since version 4, is totally closed (there is no non-api programmatic way to work with it), and has less flexibility than commonly used icon & folder systems from 1991, doesn't support ANY modern icon formats, image formats, or even custom colors. (sure, third party api tools exist, but we're talking product).
I want a modern icon/folder gui. I think he one built into the OS is the best pick, but that's not a show stopper for me.
What if the fat notes client would disappear and you had only the applications/databases that are behind the tiles in workspace as icons on your desktop? Is that not the question that Andrew really asks?
Andrew - and why?
Do you want eye candy? Fine, use the third party tools. The workspace does what it needs to do and looks how it have to look. Anything else regarding the looks maybe nice to have, but is nothing that would make it "better". It just works fine (- fine is the swabian great). I don't need to have a dashboardy thing there that sparkles and is transparent and where I can work the whole day on making my own icons and themes and whatever. For fun I used the third party tool but it doesn't change anything of the value.
@Andrew,@Martin:
"Bookmarks are fine. In fact they're much better in R8."
Are they? I disagree. The Open button is an unnecessary click more and when you dock the list you lose the titles. Which makes the user to have to remember the order of folders since you can't use individual icons any more.
And to make things even worse, they removed the possibility to display bookmark folders as workspace which worked very fine for me.
Post a comment
Recent comments
Henning Heinz
on Is 64k too much for Domino? at 13:09
Bill Buchan
on Is 64k too much for Domino? at 11:50
Volker Weber
on Is 64k too much for Domino? at 11:46
Hans-Peter Kuessner
on Is 64k too much for Domino? at 11:32
Heiko Voigt
on Is 64k too much for Domino? at 11:18
Marc Beckersjuergen
on Five people sent me a link to this video today at 11:12
Michael Preidel
on Bye bye to two subnets from India at 10:28
Stephan H. Wissel
on Bye bye to two subnets from India at 07:33
Andrew Pollack
on You can't do that in Notes at 06:22
Andrew Pollack
on Here is your chance to tell IBM what YOU want in Notes/Domino 8.5 at 23:13
Volker Weber
on Here is your chance to tell IBM what YOU want in Notes/Domino 8.5 at 22:55
Bruce Elgort
on Here is your chance to tell IBM what YOU want in Notes/Domino 8.5 at 22:49
Flemming Riis
on Bye bye to two subnets from India at 21:27
Chris Linfoot
on BlackBerry Lotus Connections client scores only 2 out of 5 at 20:09
Philipp Sury
on Free download: The Photoshop Anthology: 101 Web Design Tips, Tricks & Techniques at 17:20
Armin Auth
on Bye bye to two subnets from India at 16:48
Pieterjan Lansbergen
on Brand new Google Reader for iPhone at 16:45
Markus Dierker
on Free download: The Photoshop Anthology: 101 Web Design Tips, Tricks & Techniques at 16:40
Markus Dierker
on Brand new Google Reader for iPhone at 16:35
Ben Rose
on Brand new Google Reader for iPhone at 15:08
Pieterjan Lansbergen
on Brand new Google Reader for iPhone at 14:56
Ben Rose
on Brand new Google Reader for iPhone at 13:04
Pieterjan Lansbergen
on Office 2008 SP1 install causes setup assistant to loop at 12:44
Sven Semel
on Brand new Google Reader for iPhone at 12:43
Gregory Engels
on Office 2008 SP1 install causes setup assistant to loop at 10:09
Click here to subscribe
