Court ruling against cell phone branding
by Ragnar Schierholz
According to multiple sources (e.g. Golem, Stiftung Warentest) the Amtsgericht Potsdam (county court of Potsdam) has ruled against T-Mobile Germany (case no. 34 C 563/04) and declared the common branding of cell phones into network operator editions as illegal.
May that be a sign of hope for all users who are sick of these branded, stripped-down functionality phones that come with the plan?
The customer had complained about a special button on his Siemens A60, initially designed to access new short messages (SMS) directly but reprogrammed by the network operator to access a service subject to charge. T-Mobiles legal department claimed that the phone was not malfunctioning but working properly, as designed in T-Mobiles branded version. A non-branded version of the phone would not be available from T-Mobile. The customer filed a law-suit, to which T-Mobile did not respond at all. Thus, the judge ruled a default-decree. Again T-Mobile didn't respond, thus the ruling is effecitve now. Apparently T-Mobile wanted to keep a low profile on the case.
The rule was justified by T-Mobiles marketing promise of a Siemens A60 phone but the delivery of a non-original phone. Thus, this rule could be applied to all branded phones which are still sold under their original product name, but not for phones which are sold under a new brand of the network operator (e.g. T-Mobiles MDA series).
Comments
"A non-branded version of the phone would not available from T-Mobile."
should either read:
"A non-branded version of the phone would not be available from T-Mobile."
or
"A non-branded version of the phone is/was not available from T-Mobile."
:-)
Ooops, corrected that.
>and declared the common branding of cell phones into network operator
>editions as illegal.
Wow, did we really read the same news-article? I came away with a totally different interpretation...
@Sencer: Well, the court has not yet published the rule online (at least I couldn't find it, but some articles said the ruling declared the branding as "unzulässig" which can be translated to illegal.
To put it clear:
The branding itself is not subject of the rule, but the distribution if the manipulated/branded phone under it's original product name with the original manuals etc. is. The customer was promised (in this case) a Siemens A60 phone and apparently received one (incl. the original Siemens manual). But the phone's software was altered to request a service subject to charge when a particular button was pushed. Siemens' manual and the on-screen manual said the button would open unread short messages (SMS). That was a misleading of the customer and is declared as "unzulässig".
In other words, if an MNO wants to offer branded phones (especially with less functionality), they have to offer them under a different name.
I'm wondering why you are linking to Golem instead of Heise online - Urteil gegen Handy-Branding. Are you going to diversify your media contacts? ;-)
Wups, I just recognized it was Ragnar, not Volker who wrote that article. Sorry for that ;-)
@Markus: I take that as a compliment ;-)
Post a comment
Recent comments
Ingo Martinz on Meeeeeeeeeeep at 22:32
Axel Koerv on Meeeeeeeeeeep at 21:57
Roland Dressler on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 11:50
Karl Heindel on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 10:30
Jerry Preissler on LibreOffice vs Apache OpenOffice at 13:47
Mariano Kamp on How to commit at 09:41
Bernd Vellguth on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 02:05
Thilo Hamberger on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 16:40
Jens Bruntt on Free PlayBook for your Android app submission at 11:47
Karl Heindel on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 20:26
Roland Dressler on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 15:12
Stephan H. Wissel on heise online: IBM plant Stellenabbau in Deutschland at 08:38
Jan Lauer on heise online: IBM plant Stellenabbau in Deutschland at 04:13
Juergen Heinrich on Balance at 03:29
Jörg Hermann on Girls On Longboards at 02:42
Stephan H. Wissel on heise online: IBM plant Stellenabbau in Deutschland at 23:21
Joerg Michael on heise online: IBM plant Stellenabbau in Deutschland at 21:01
Ben Poole on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 19:46
David Hablewitz on BlackBerry Business Cloud Services with Microsoft Office 365 at 16:44
Patrick Picard on RIM tries to be social. Falls flat on face. at 16:00
Volker Weber on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 10:29
Richard Hogan on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 10:26
Joachim Haydecker on Girls On Longboards at 08:26
Karl Heindel on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 07:50
Keith Brooks on Outlook to Notes converter: from PST to NSF at 04:21


