The owner of Planet Lotus, Yancy Lent, asked me yesterday if he should move this site to "Planet Sharepoint" instead. ... I said no, don't move it, ... However, he seems quite insistent and hinted that he'd have to "de-list" me in the interim ...
I cannot believe that Yancy Lent is behind this stupid idea.
I think too much is being read into this.
Yancy has a companion “Planet” site for Sharepoint, and looking at the SP sites out there, not many people are writing the sort of stuff Jake is: I can understand why Yancy would want Jake’s posts on Planet Sharepoint.
I haven’t seen anything from anyone that categorically states, “Thou shalt be de-listed from PlanetLotus henceforth” and I know Jake takes exception to his content being aggregated / published elsewhere, so I don’t imagine for one moment that he would entertain the idea of a separate newsfeed purely for his Sharepoint stuff (or whatever).
It’s just a lot of hot air I reckon. Otherwise, many many others would face “de-listing”—you and me included.
Point taken. But why would Yancy suggest that he would have to de-list Jake?
It's a conspiracy, don'tchaknow?!
Seriously, I get Jake's want for publishing the story... but how does this post help the "yellow bubble" that it's specifically targeted for?
It's your site, so by all means post what you want... but regardless of the technology or platform discussed, I think it's all just disruptive chatter that distracts people from the posts that actually will help them with their jobs.
Just my opinion, as you are entitled to your own.
I am not really sure what you want to say. I know it's my site, and I can pretty much say what I want. On site, and off site. So what are you on about?
I'm sure lots of people want to hide the dirty laundry but I'm glad to know at least a bit about what's going on.
I just discovered PlanetLotus only recently and, frankly, for me it isn't that useful. I don't care if Jake is listed on it or not; CodeStore is in my RSS reader and is the first blog I look at every day. I'm sorry he hasn't embraced xPages because then I'd have a better resource for learning it myself.
As far as I'm concerned, CodeStore is still the best Notes/Domino blog that I read. So PlanetLotus thinking about de-listing it says more to me about PlanetLotus than about CodeStore. It says to me that diversity of opinion is not welcome there.
Don't let this place become the TMZ of the yellowverse
You can read the full email exchange here: http://planetlotus.org/6f93c0
Thanks, Yancy. Added as an update to the post.
It still seems a lot of fuss about nothing to me (especially when you skim some of the comments at codestore: “over-reaction” isn’t the half of it).
I can see both points of view, and fail to understand why a perfectly amicable compromise / arrangement can’t be reached. It seems odd that Jake calls out Yancy for “going public” with the email thread when he started the whole thing in the first place.
Hey ho, just another PL storm in a teacup :-)
That is basically Ed's tweet which I added to the comments over at Jake's. Maybe everything can just stay as it has worked well so far.
Woh. Too many conversations going on about this now.
I agree. It's getting just a bit out of control (I never mean it to) and expect to find out soon it was all some elaborate publicity exercise for Planet Sharepoint. How many people know it exists now that didn't this morning?
I just seem to have a nack to alienate people (sorry Ben, I know you're one of them). Kind of wish I could just brush it all under the carpet and pretend it never happened.
@ben. I didn't call him out for going public (or did I?). I just don't see what he aimed to achieve from it.
Jake: you’re an excellent writer, with a keen eye for the UI (ooh poetry). You haven’t alienated anyone from where I’m standing, so keep doing what you do.
Jens Nullmeyer on Photos :: Google got the message at 16:07
Andre Hausberger on Photos :: Google got the message at 15:17
Daniel Haferkorn on Photos :: Google got the message at 11:30
Volker Weber on Photos :: Google got the message at 10:47
Samuel Orsenne on Photos :: Google got the message at 10:28
Frank Koehntopp (@koehntopp) on Photos :: Google got the message at 10:06
Ingo Harpel on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 09:55
Michael Baum on Pebble Time :: Ceci n'est pas une critique at 08:47
Haiko Hebig on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 00:12
Volker Weber on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 22:05
Volker Weber on Pebble Time :: Ceci n'est pas une critique at 21:58
Wolf Fischer on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 18:25
Wolf Fischer on Mary Meeker's Internet Trends 2015 at 18:17
Ralph Hammann on Pebble Time :: Ceci n'est pas une critique at 16:01
Joseph Federer on Pebble Time :: Ceci n'est pas une critique at 15:23
Michael Baum on Pebble Time :: Ceci n'est pas une critique at 15:03
Joachim Haydecker on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 14:52
Lars Berntrop-Bos on Mary Meeker's Internet Trends 2015 at 14:09
Ralph Hammann on Pebble Time :: Ceci n'est pas une critique at 13:33
Kai Bode on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 13:24
Hubert Stettner on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 11:51
Stephan Perthes on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 10:36
Stefan Domanske on Lesson of the day :: Knowledge is not understanding at 10:17
Hogne B. Pettersen on IBM Verse UI challenges :: Icons at 10:04
Manfred Wiktorin on tizi Turbolader 4x Mega at 18:06