Joel: Now would be a good time to buy stock in Internet flamewars

by Volker Weber

Imagine that you went to Mars, where you discovered that the beings who live there don’t have the portable music player. They’re still using boom boxes.

You realize this is a huge business opportunity and start selling portable MP3 players (except on Mars they’re called Qxyzrhjjjjukltks) and compatible headphones.

Follow Joel on his journey to explain requirements for backwards compatibility. He is a brilliant writer who only lacks the ability to make his point with a short story. So pour yourself a fresh cup of coffee and get cracking.

More >

Comments

How true that is! He writes beautiful and interesting stuff, but it's difficult to find excuses to take the necessary half-day off to read through his latest piece, follow up all the links and do it proper justice.

Nick Daisley, 2008-03-18

Mark Pilgrim's take on Joel is also fun to read...

Armin Auth, 2008-03-18

Mark is the idealist. ;-)

Volker Weber, 2008-03-18

true, but without his comment it would be only half the fun. And despite all, both are usually a worthwhile read.

Armin Auth, 2008-03-18

Mark is the idealist. ;-)That’s one word for him… ;o)

Ben Poole, 2008-03-18

So Joel Spolsky wants us to believe that the special behaviour of IE6/7 is caused by a legitimate interpretation of very complicated and vague standards. The IE team tried its best but unfortunatly web pages don't look the same in IE as in other browsers. That's naive. Microsoft deliberately violated standards like CSS or DOM by implementing them only partially or simply ignoring the spec. Who really believes that this impressive list of bugs and errors is just the fault of a bad standard, when almost every other vendor is able to comply with it?

Wolfgang Sommergut, 2008-03-19

It's fair to say that *some* of the rendering oddities in any browser are due to complicated and vague standards. HTML was intended to define semantic structure around text for generic browsers, not to build crazy, visually rich web applications. Furthermore, new versions have to support old bad behavior from previous versions, at least for a while. This is not an excuse, but a partial explanation. The issue is more and less complicated than Joel made it out to be. Here's my take:

http://www.robbyslaughter.com/blog/?2008-03-21

Robby Slaughter, 2008-03-22

Recent comments

Volker Weber on Marshall Monitor II A.N.C. :: Erste Eindrücke at 08:13
Maikel Maes on Marshall Monitor II A.N.C. :: Erste Eindrücke at 07:58
Jochen Kattoll on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 22:21
Harald Gärttner on Microsoft Office app on Android and iOS at 15:09
Volker Weber on App-Store-Interna: Apple geht gegen Buchveröffentlichung vor at 14:55
Oliver Stör on App-Store-Interna: Apple geht gegen Buchveröffentlichung vor at 13:42
Volker Weber on Microsoft Office app on Android and iOS at 13:02
Harald Gärttner on Microsoft Office app on Android and iOS at 12:56
Volker Weber on Marshall Monitor II A.N.C. :: Erste Eindrücke at 08:07
Thomas Cloer on Marshall Monitor II A.N.C. :: Erste Eindrücke at 07:57
Matthias Lorz on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 12:47
Volker Weber on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 11:54
Fabio Peruzzi on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 11:48
Fabio Peruzzi on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 11:45
Horia Stanescu on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 07:04
Martin Funk on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 00:00
Sven Bühler on I am not ready for a foldable phone at 22:03
Andreas Imnitzer on The Neighbor’s Window :: Oscar Winning Short Film at 21:48
Roland Dressler on I am not ready for a foldable phone at 15:02
Daniel Seiler on I am not ready for a foldable phone at 13:51
Roland Dressler on I am not ready for a foldable phone at 12:55
Hubert Stettner on I am not ready for a foldable phone at 10:51
Matthias Welling on Tools and Weapons #nowreading at 09:05
Ingo Harpel on You may secretly be a Bing user at 20:01
Amy Blumenfield on Tools and Weapons #nowreading at 19:44

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 13:09

visitors.gif

Paypal vowe