Lotus Notes RSS reader unsafe

by Volker Weber

The vulnerability is universal. You don't need any exploit. Notes downloads HTML code embedded into the RSS feed, dumps it into the file system and asks Internet Explorer to interpret it. Since the file is local, IE treats it as local code. From there you can do pretty much everything that is possible with Javascript, Flash or other embedded code.

Interesting time line:

2009/04/07 Identification of the vulnerability.
2009/04/23 Notification of IBM via the customer.
2009/04/23 Technical knowhow exchange between scip AG/IBM.
2009/06/05 Asking for current status by scip AG. (no answer)
2009/07/09 Asking for current status by scip AG.
2009/07/09 Reply with current status and assigned PMR.
2009/08/24 Asking for current status by scip AG. (no answer)
2009/09/08 Public disclosure of the advisory.

Published by IBM today. If you need to fix, you have to contact IBM Support.

Comments

this might be a stupid question but if you have to log a call wont you need a support contract ? or does that not apply to security fixes

Flemming Riis, 2009-09-18 19:43

Another stupid question - HTML formatted emails are rendered by Internet Exploder too.

That must also be done in the local context. If you have ever printed an HTML email from Notes 8+ you will know that you get the standard IE print header and footer complete with the local URL in the footer.

Someone please tell me there isn't a code execution possibility right there.

Chris Linfoot, 2009-09-18 20:20

Best bet is to open a call and find out. (I am not sure if you can or not). Either way there are 3 other options you can do in the meantime.

By the way. The Technote was not published today (only updated today). It was posted before scip AG posted the exploit publicly.

Simon O'Doherty, 2009-09-18 20:23

@Chris - Actually, HTML formatted emails as "cleaned up" first to prevent malicious code. The cleanup may not be perfect, but it is a different scenario.

Ben Langhinrichs, 2009-09-18 20:24

@Ben is that clean up exactly documented somewhere?

Jan-Piet Mens, 2009-09-18 20:39

@Chris, @Ben,

I fear you are both missing the point. The problem is that the Notes RSS reader, dumps the HTML into a local file on the user's PC. When IE is then invoked to render that local file, it does so outside its sandbox.

When IE, as a browser, renders HTML received from an HTTP source, it does so in its sandbox. Now one could argue about how effective that sandbox is, but that is a whole other issue!

Nick Shelness, 2009-09-19 09:45

@Nick: Neither Chris nor Ben talked about HTML from an HTTP source, but from HTML included in formatted mails from outside. I think it's not too unlikely the same happens with them.

But BTW: isn't that what every other local RSS reader application would do?

Oliver Regelmann, 2009-09-19 20:34

No, they don't. It's a very basic design failure. Other feed readers like FeedDemon use the proper Internet sandbox.

If you start digging around in the "standard" client outside of what used to be Notes, you will find lots of stuff that will lead to more security discussions. Code signing, ECL etc don't exist there. And you are supposed to turn malware protection off in this space, so that performance does not suffer.

Volker Weber, 2009-09-19 20:51

Well, who's to bless & who's to blame ? One of the biggest questions on opening the Notes Client to the Eclipse platform for me was about security of plugins. The monolitic C++ Notes Client was much less vulnarable to lazy programmers than the open Eclipse platform is. That IBM itself had to prove that is some sort irony to me. Eclipse is a blessing and a curse - flexibilty and openness always means responsibility... . And - don't get me wrong - even with this, I appreciate the way, IBM is heading with Notes 8.x, Eclipse and Expeditor.

Heiko Voigt, 2009-09-19 22:48

It's probably a matter of trust. If you want to use widgets, you have to trust them. If you can't trust a plugin from IBM, whom do you want to trust? The RSS widget is a perfect malware dropper. Access to the local file system, ability to run processes in user space.

Volker Weber, 2009-09-19 23:04

@Vowe: So when I use a feedreader with offline capabilities (I think most of the popular do), I would load the HTML from the local file system as well?

Stephan H. Wissel, 2009-09-21 05:03

Lotus Notes RSS reader is a joke anyway.

Roman Kopac, 2009-09-30 13:54

Recent comments

Sabine Kluge on Alex und Kira :: Eine ganz persönliche Perspektive at 18:49
Thomas C. Knodt on Alex und Kira :: Eine ganz persönliche Perspektive at 15:42
Otto Foerg on Restart completed at 15:15
Ulli Mueller on Restart completed at 14:09
Eric Bredtmann on Restart completed at 13:21
Jochen Kattoll on Alex und Kira :: Eine ganz persönliche Perspektive at 12:24
Dirk Steins on Restart completed at 12:13
Markus Dierker on Alex und Kira :: Eine ganz persönliche Perspektive at 12:03
Mariano Kamp on Alex und Kira :: Eine ganz persönliche Perspektive at 11:24
Alper Iseri on Alex und Kira :: Eine ganz persönliche Perspektive at 11:00
Stephan Perthes on Restart completed at 10:21
Markus Dierker on Sonos One needs serious b/s detection at 09:47
Ingo Harpel on Restart completed at 09:26
Maikel Maes on Restart completed at 08:13
Richard Schwartz on Restart completed at 07:28
Owen Menck on Restart completed at 00:42
Rod Stauffer on Restart completed at 00:11
Oliver Busse on Restart completed at 23:20
John Keys on Restart completed at 22:27
Craig Wiseman on Restart completed at 21:28
Michael Urspringer on Restart completed at 21:26
Thomas Lang on Restart completed at 20:51
Armin Auth on Restart completed at 19:54
Abdelkader Boui on Restart completed at 19:34
Andrew Magerman on Dramatische 24 Stunden at 18:12

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter

Local time is 19:30

visitors.gif