Do you need a new iPad now?

by Volker Weber

The short answer is the same as with the iPad 2: No. But then it gets complicated.

When Apple released the first iPad, they got everything right. It was perfect. With the iPad 2 they added a few things and made it faster. Not so much faster, that you needed to upgrade for the speed. The things they added were brilliant, like the smartcover, and crappy like the cameras. It was a bit lighter and had a more practical back which lay flat on a table.

The New iPad however is not the iPad 3, although everybody calls it that. It's truly a new iPad. Why? Because the iPad is a screen canvas for your apps. The device itself isn't important. What's happening on your screen is. And the new screen drives everything else. Apple needed to add a much bigger battery which made the new iPad heavier and thicker than the old one, lighter and thinner than the original iPad, mind you. They needed to boost the graphics engine to be able to drive the new screen with the same speed as the old one.

A larger battery takes longer to charge. If it discharges in the same 10 hours as the old one, it draws more current. More current in and out means more heat. If you read reports on the Internet you may think that is a problem. It isn't. Reviewers are struggling to find negative aspects of the device and that's all they can come up with. More weight, more heat. Not as thin as the old one. By 0.6 millimeter!

Frankly, all of that does not matter. It's the screen. Only the screen. Yes, better cameras, yada yada. But look at this screen. It has print resolution. You can read everything without zooming, pinching or dragging. Just the whole page. Goodreader updated yesterday to support the new screen resolution. What a difference!

It's going to take a while for all major apps to upgrade. Not long though. Do yourself a favor if you own an iPad or an iPad 2. Don't look at the New iPad. Your device is wonderful. And you will do exactly the same things with a new iPad that you do with your current iPad. You don't need a new iPad.

Just. Don't. Look. At. The. Screen.

ZZ121CE948

Comments

Sent my new ipad back to apple. The new screen might be amazing. But i was affected from "yellowgate".

Roland Dressler, 2012-03-23

Volker is spot-on in his summary as probably always.
The screen is the game changer. Everything displaying text is in another league now. The problems brought up by some are not really problematic. Maybe apart from yellow screens if yours is affected.

Also a good business move from iA to have Writer retina enabled on launch day. I would like to see the impact on sales. In the past Oliver had shared some interesting sales numbers i.e. at iCloud launch (https://plus.google.com/115711522874757126523/posts/PoPTYdVFYyt)

Upgraded from the first iPad. I have to confess that coming from the original iPad the speed increase also feels significant. Especially iBooks and other reader rendering non-vector PDF pages (the tiles appearing faster). But that may just be personal impression. I'd think the overall "speed" should be the same as with the iPad 2 if you already have one of those.

Tobias Hauser, 2012-03-23

Upgraded from the original iPad to the new iPad and I'm so glad I did. Don't get me wrong the original iPad was still doing the job (awesome device) but with the new retina display friendly apps coming out I knew it was time to step it up. People complain about how hot the new iPad gets but it's no different then my android phone or even My TV when it's on. Granted I'm not holding my TV in my hands when I'm watching it but the new iPad is an electronic device and electronic devices get warm when in use especially when charging.

Jav Tejada, 2012-03-23

I didn't buy the iPad 1 or 2.

I will buy the latest version.

Having played with Android for the last number of years, the issue of fragmentation has finally convinced me that iOS devices are the better consumer option (i.e. able to run the new version of the OS one year after product launch, unlike my one year old Desire HD).

That is another topic, though.

Stephen Mooney, 2012-03-23

Dont forget, the only reason for the extraordinary resolution of the new retina display is to be compatible to older devices and apps. No scaling effects! And, no fragmentation issues!

Roland Dressler, 2012-03-23

Yes, going back to the 2 after using my wife's The New iPad is quite jarring. This could quickly turn into a "Hurry up and put it down dear" game ;)

Colin Williams , 2012-03-24

Vowe, This may be the best article you have posted on your site. It's clear and to the point, does away with the rhetorical statements and dismisses the false notions and gives the reader the important facts and information about the product. No tech specs, which are not needed for a proper review and the most important statement, if you currently own an iPad , you don't need to buy another one unless you feel compelled to. Finally like you said "don't look at the screen", if your 51 like me with eyes getting worse every year the screen not the CPU is everything! bravo.

Rich Hunter, 2012-04-04

Recent comments

Volker Weber on Fritz!Fon C4, C5 und C6 :: Stuff that works at 23:17
Ragnar Schierholz on Fritz!Fon C4, C5 und C6 :: Stuff that works at 23:08
Jan Fuellemann on ANC Schalter für Beats Studio 3 in iOS 13 at 17:10
Volker Weber on Recording video on iPhone with Buetooth headset at 00:01
Gregory Engels on Recording video on iPhone with Buetooth headset at 22:41
Martin Hiegl on Cryptodamages: Monetary value estimates of the air pollution and human health impacts of cryptocurrency mining at 17:45
Markus Dierker on Recording video on iPhone with Buetooth headset at 08:25
Volker Weber on Cryptodamages: Monetary value estimates of the air pollution and human health impacts of cryptocurrency mining at 22:48
Maximilian von Hulewicz on Cryptodamages: Monetary value estimates of the air pollution and human health impacts of cryptocurrency mining at 08:09
Andreas Weinreich on Withings ECG :: Erste Eindrücke at 21:30
Andy Mell on Very fast October update for Galaxy S10 at 18:56
Volker Weber on Withings ECG :: Erste Eindrücke at 16:53
Bernd Fellerhoff on Withings ECG :: Erste Eindrücke at 15:23
Stanislaus Landeis on iCloud Drive file sharing delayed until spring 2020 at 12:55
Volker Weber on AirPlay 2 richtig verwenden at 11:52
Matthias Welling on AirPlay 2 richtig verwenden at 09:30
Volker Weber on AirPlay 2 richtig verwenden at 23:10
Steve Smillie on Very fast October update for Galaxy S10 at 21:58
Ragnar Schierholz on AirPlay 2 richtig verwenden at 21:34
Ragnar Schierholz on Withings ECG :: Erste Eindrücke at 18:05
Peter Meuser on Endlich habe ich Samsung DeX kapiert at 17:00
Torsten Pinkert on Very fast October update for Galaxy S10 at 16:45
Christian Tillmanns on Cryptodamages: Monetary value estimates of the air pollution and human health impacts of cryptocurrency mining at 16:17
Armin Auth on Lenovo Chromebook C340-11 #stuffthatworks at 11:49
Maximilian von Hulewicz on Cryptodamages: Monetary value estimates of the air pollution and human health impacts of cryptocurrency mining at 10:06

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 05:29

visitors.gif

buy me coffee

Paypal vowe