The big elephant in the AI room

by Volker Weber

I am watching all these demos from Google, Microsoft and IBM - yes, IBM - and everything looks oh so impressive. And then it fails as soon as you are not using a single language. Microsoft Cortana for instance fails as soon as you are using an English version Windows with a German locale. Game over. Cortana and Siri can only understand one language. How easy would it be to discover when I switch from German to English and back? It's just that nobody thought of that. Cognitive? Bah, humbug.

Comments

Representing a household in which German, Spanish and English is regularly written and spoken I can only agree wholeheartedly.

Frank Quednau, 2016-03-31

for a long time using Siri to play music did not work because I have Siri configured in German and it had a hard time with the English band names and song titles.

With iOS 9.3 this has gotten lot better, just tried about 20 different bands and 18 of them worked.

Eddie Cue is talking about these improvements in the Talk Show Episode 146:
https://daringfireball.net/thetalkshow/2016/02/12/ep-146

on the Apple TV it has gotten a lot better to with the last update

Thomas Einwaller, 2016-03-31

...and Microsoft's Tay just went amok again ;).

Ingo Seifert, 2016-03-31

Slightly off topic:

This reminds me of a task back in the year of 2000 during the "Bundeswettbewerb Informatik". You had to write a program which analyzes and recognizes the language of any given text file. I wonder why this hasn't been implemented yet in voice recognition as even my solution was pretty simple and stupid but had even an option to add own language files, a self-learning module and a hit rate above 95% based on over 10.000 txt files. Good old times... ;-)

Here's the original task (page 6, task 3): http://www.bundeswettbewerb-informatik.de/uploads/media/download/191aufgaben.pdf

And for all interested: coded with Turbo Pascal 6.0 on a Pentium II 400 MHz as a pure DOS program ;-)

Thanks Volker for bringing back those memories.

Mathias Ziolo, 2016-03-31

Mit Siri geht es mittlerweile recht gut.

Wie bereits von Thomas geschrieben: In einem Interview spricht Apple direkt dieses Problem an und dessen Herausforderung - aber auch deren beabsichtigte Lösung.

Bernd Schuster, 2016-03-31

Isn't voice recognition only one facet of AI?

Bruce Elgort, 2016-03-31

Recent comments

Dirk Bartkowiak on Want at 13:32
Samuel Orsenne on Want at 13:30
Roland Dressler on Want at 13:15
Volker Weber on Want at 11:37
Matthias Welling on Want at 11:16
Karl Heindel on Want at 11:09
Dominique Roller on Want at 10:55
Stephan Perthes on Want at 10:37
Patrick Bohr on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 09:21
Karl Heindel on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 09:04
Armin Auth on Apple Watch Activity Competition #dontbreakthechain at 09:04
Felix Binsack on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 07:38
Michael Urspringer on Themenwechsel at 07:03
Andreas Braukmann on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 00:30
Volker Weber on Themenwechsel at 23:40
Volker Weber on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 23:13
Karl Heindel on Themenwechsel at 23:12
Volker Weber on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 21:51
Marco Foellmer on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 21:42
Frank Heurich on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 21:07
Volker Weber on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 20:14
Michael Jäckel on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 20:06
Felix Binsack on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 18:46
Volker Weber on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 16:25
Volker Weber on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 15:01

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 15:11

visitors.gif

buy me coffee