How to route Dolby Digital 5.1 from Apple TV through a Samsung TV to Sonos Playbar

by Volker Weber

a5ffdb5bfe29a25dd14969f5730040ca

This was a tough nut to crack, and in the end if was quite easy.

Popular knowledge is that Samsung TVs don't play DD 5.1 from HDMI connected sources. I was this close to solving this with an HDMI splitter connected to HDMI 2 ARC and a Toslink Out to Playbar. As it turns out this is not a problem to solve on the output side but on the link between the Samsung TV and your source, here an Apple TV.

a0db337cbdeac89b64dcc0ffbe3f4ec2

The keyword is Extended Display Identification Data (EDID). Samsung tells the Apple TV to not bother sending anything but PCM Stereo. And here is the trick. You go into the audio settings of Apple TV and tell it to send Dolby Digital 5.1 instead of "best available". Then Apple TV ignores the EDID and just sends DD 5.1. While the video is playing, you go into audio settings on the Samsung TV and suddenly Dolby Digital is available. Select that option.

b7813e3c4af850f85ba019a78bac5785

Problem solved. No hardware required.

I would bet this works for other sources like Xbox or FireTV as well.

Comments

Thanks for that tip! This type of information is extremely hard to find.

Markus Dierker, 2017-04-11 14:51

Thx for the tip - am getting a PlayBase and was wondering how to do that :o)

Ursus Schneider, 2017-04-11 15:46

Das funktioniert auch mit FireTV (Stick) schon seit Anfang an und bei mir im Übrigen ohne jeglichen Eingriff. Und auch der Samsung BR-Player liefert seinen 5.1-Ton an die Playbar, nachdem man in den Einstellungen ein festes Recoding auf DD 5.1 eingestellt hat. Ja, ja ... die Mehrkanalton-Enthusiasten werden dabei stöhnen, aber für den Hausgebrauch reicht mir das komplett. Kein wirklich hörbarer Unterschied zum Original-DTS und keine spürbaren Einbußen durch das Recoding. Bin mit dem Mehrkanalton der Playbar aus allen Quellen absolut zufrieden.

Tobias Vogel, 2017-04-12 13:35

Funny -- I do exactly the opposite to force the AppleTV to send two channels to my setup. I find 5.1 annoying.

Eric Hancock, 2017-04-16 00:32

Post a comment

Store next two fields in a cookie for you?




Use your full name and a working email address. Unless you want your comment to be removed. No kidding.

Recent comments

Volker Weber on Windows 10 on iPad Pro? at 12:49
Reinhard Fellner on Windows 10 on iPad Pro? at 12:47
Stephen Kelly on Wishlist for #Sonos :: The results at 20:14
Volker Weber on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 19:10
Andy Mell on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 19:04
Volker Weber on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 16:32
Daniel Meyer on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 16:31
Volker Weber on Wishlist for #Sonos :: The results at 13:46
Hanno Zulla on Wishlist for #Sonos :: The results at 13:42
Ralph Inselsbacher on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 13:39
Volker Weber on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 13:31
Ralph Inselsbacher on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 13:26
Volker Weber on Wishlist for #Sonos :: The results at 13:18
Manfred Wiktorin on Wishlist for #Sonos :: The results at 12:27
Ralph Inselsbacher on Stuff that works :: Marshall Monitor Bluetooth at 11:36
Manfred Wiktorin on Wishlist for #Sonos :: The results at 20:05
Volker Weber on Bad streaming and good streaming at 20:10
Sven Bühler on Bad streaming and good streaming at 20:09
Manfred Wiktorin on Bad streaming and good streaming at 15:45
Volker Weber on Bad streaming and good streaming at 15:29
Manfred Wiktorin on Bad streaming and good streaming at 15:25
Stefan Dorscht on Bad streaming and good streaming at 14:38
Volker Weber on Sonos, please update your ancient network stack at 21:29
Johannes Matzke on Sonos, please update your ancient network stack at 21:06
Daniel Meyer on Sonos, please update your ancient network stack at 19:04

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter

Local time is 12:40

visitors.gif