Samsung Galaxy S8 :: The verdict

by Volker Weber

e1cabf7fc0edb6586c8dae5808774eaf

I have used the Galaxy S8 for a week, and by the end of the month, it will be back at Samsung. By and large it behaved exactly like I expected. But I have softened by judgement somewhat.

The S8 is an almost perfect smartphone. There are only two compromises: Samsung had to move the fingerprint sensor to the back, next to the camera. It would have been better placed underneath the camera, but that is where the battery and the wireless charging sit. Yes, you will touch the camera, but that is not a big deal, if you clean it once in a while. The app reminds you to do that. The other compromise is the mono speaker. You can watch beautiful videos in wide screen, but the sound comes out of one end. This device really needs stereo speakers.

With these exceptions, the S8 is best in class. Period.

When you build an Android phone and you want access to Google Play Store and Google Play Services, then Google dictates what you need to deliver with your phone. When you are Samsung and you have ambitions beyond being yet another Android OEM, then you need to also deliver your own software. The user ends up with two of everything. But Samsung is getting better at this. Samsung Experience, formerly known as TouchWiz, is now very elegantly designed, it does not bog down the hardware, and it is actually a joy to use.

Here is my recommendation: if you buy a Galaxy S8, then go with the Samsung Experience. Don't just replace the launcher with the Google Launcher and ignore what Samsung has built. You are fighting with your phone and that will be a frustrating experience. Sign up to a Samsung ID, get Bixby going, help it learn your ways.

And here is my problem: I cannot do that. I do not trust Samsung. Samsung destroyed my trust with their TV. It's not my TV, although I paid for it. Samsung pushes their software and their apps into my TV experience. And I can already smell the same behaviour with Bixby. I never have this feeling with Apple. Microsoft is sort of borderline. But Samsung is not with me. If you don't have my problem, then by all means, buy this machine. You will love it.

The bigger question is of course: do you trust Google?

Comments

Volker, I purchased my Samsung TV one year after you purchased your Samsung TV. And I am much more satisfied with my TV than you with yours. That one year seems to be a major difference. I do receive regular software updates and the software does get better. The software does seem to be the same as on the latest Samsung TVs that I bought for the company. Deleted apps do not get installed again either.

Felix Binsack, 2017-04-23

You might not have the feeling with Apple, but it is there.
If you are not using the keychain, have switched off Hey Siri or don't want to use iCloud Apple annoys you big time with every software udpate.

Patrick Bohr, 2017-04-24

Felix, good for you, but not for me. Mine gets an update once in a while, but Samsung keeps selling more than 50% of the smart hub UI to their "trusted partners". Until Samsung fixes this, I won't be buying another TV from them.

Patrick, I have switched off (or rather not switched on) Hey Siri, I use iCloud for some basic stuff (I don't pay Apple), and I am really fine. Apple treats me well.

Volker Weber, 2017-04-24

My Samsung Smart TV is not connected to the network. Why should it be ? I get all apps i like an need on my AppleTV (80% usage incl. NAS playback, Youtube etc.) and FireTV (20% usage, only Amazon content). They don't annoy me with ads and their stuff works fine.

Thomas Klein, 2017-04-24

Wait three years. The S11 will be stereo and it will go to 11.

Richard Schwartz, 2017-04-25

I can't wait until TV and other "smart" systems start build Aircrack or similar into their devices so they can get on WiFi in spite of the owners wishes.

Bill Brown, 2017-04-25

Recent comments

Dirk Bartkowiak on Want at 13:32
Samuel Orsenne on Want at 13:30
Roland Dressler on Want at 13:15
Volker Weber on Want at 11:37
Matthias Welling on Want at 11:16
Karl Heindel on Want at 11:09
Dominique Roller on Want at 10:55
Stephan Perthes on Want at 10:37
Patrick Bohr on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 09:21
Karl Heindel on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 09:04
Armin Auth on Apple Watch Activity Competition #dontbreakthechain at 09:04
Felix Binsack on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 07:38
Michael Urspringer on Themenwechsel at 07:03
Andreas Braukmann on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 00:30
Volker Weber on Themenwechsel at 23:40
Volker Weber on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 23:13
Karl Heindel on Themenwechsel at 23:12
Volker Weber on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 21:51
Marco Foellmer on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 21:42
Frank Heurich on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 21:07
Volker Weber on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 20:14
Michael Jäckel on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 20:06
Felix Binsack on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 18:46
Volker Weber on Apple Music :: Erfolgreicher Umstieg at 16:25
Volker Weber on Sonos Play:3 :: Nicht kaufen, nicht warten at 15:01

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 15:35

visitors.gif

buy me coffee