Change isn't always progress

by Volker Weber

ZZ5E10F471

The Sonos UX on macOS hasn't been updated in years and it is so much easier to use than on iOS.

Comments

I fully concur. The UI on the desktop looks a bit dated and dark, but it is super-fast and easy to use.
The iOS Apps used to be similar, but the new UI there still manages to confuse me. Still hoping that users will be heard and that they revert back to the old more easy navigation. Did they skip user testing or do we just not get it?

Jens Nullmeyer, 2017-11-30

Exactly.
The latest iOS Sonos app ist just a mess. I.E. changing rooms does not work as it should - sometimes it does, sometimes not. Previous app was ok, so (my local) WLAN is not the problem. Sonos MUST get better.

Stephan Perthes, 2017-11-30

Echo that. iOS app drove me crazy with rooms and groups and navigation taking a very long time to understand. And even then... I keep doing it wrong. It’s just not intuitive. If end users keep doing it wrong, UX is off.

Maikel Maes, 2017-11-30

I would agree completely. I use about 30/70 macOS/iOS for controlling Sonos. Much easier and way less frustrating.

The only detrimental change I've seen is that removed the "A-Z" shortcuts (RH side) a few versions back when browsing a music library. That's still present in the iOS version.

Chris Lindley, 2017-11-30

Well, I’d say the app improved. The main buttons on the bottom make reach easier for big screens. The true issue for me is that when you choose a room and then look for music for it, you lose the context, that is pretty weird. Also searching over all sources is useless as I cannot control what is searched and in which priority.

Frank Quednau, 2017-11-30

There are a lot of people that say the exact opposite about that desktop app. Include me to them. It looks pretty dated and has a lot of design patterns that seem not to match to todays use cases.

Having used Sonos for about three years now, I don't see any major problems with the new design on iOS

Christian Gut, 2017-11-30

The one thing I am constantly missing is that I can predefine some often used combinations to quickly regroup some rooms.

Christian Gut, 2017-11-30

In this case change is indeed not progress, and this ever since they switched to the "modern" iOS design. Already back then Sonos did not take feedback very well and apparently can't get it right to meet expectations of their "old" customers ...

Frank Terhorst, 2017-11-30

@Christian: Did you have a look at Macronos (Android) or SonoSequencr (iOS)? They should support your use case (at the cost of € and an additional app).

[Disclaimer: I do not use any of these]

Jonas

Jonas Rathert, 2017-11-30

Precisely. The same is true for the Windows version. Oldie but goldie.

Remember the first incarnation of the „new“ V5.0 iOS app back in 2014? It was a complete and utter mess, but gradually improved over time until it became fairly usable in 2016. I sometimes missed the familiar 4.3 version, though. The post „Don't Like the New App v5.0“ still is the entry with most comments in the SONOS community forums.

Now SONOS broke the app again. Not as hard as 3 years ago, but the logic behind the redesign escapes me. DON'T MAKE ME THINK. Nor guess, for that matter.

Pretty please!

Jörg Weske, 2017-12-01

Funny enough I am missing the third party controller 'Zonos' from the windows phone / mobile times 😆

Hubert Stettner, 2017-12-01

That is running on Windows 10 just fine.

Volker Weber, 2017-12-01

Yeah, but not on my Android devices.

Hubert Stettner, 2017-12-01

Thumbs up! That new iOS controller is a usability disaster.

Hans Bornich, 2017-12-04

Recent comments

Jochen Schug on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 17:59
Michael Hertlein on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 14:53
Patrick Bohr on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 11:00
Roland Dressler on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 10:43
Arne Sigurd Rognan Nielsen on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 10:40
Frank Köhler on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 18:55
Jochen Schug on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 17:28
Michael Hertlein on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 16:52
Friedrich Holstein on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 16:41
Volker Weber on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 14:43
Michael Hertlein on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 13:44
Stefan Kremer on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 12:44
Volker Weber on Invoxia Triby :: Ein starker Zwerg at 10:44
Frank Köhler on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 21:00
Sven Bühler on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 20:44
Dominique Roller on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 20:05
Martin Kirchler on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 16:12
Volker Weber on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 16:06
Roland Dressler on Lange erwartet :: Neue AirPods at 15:31
Dietmar Liehr on Gestern in der Tagesschau at 12:55
Torsten Armbruster on Invoxia Triby :: Ein starker Zwerg at 12:49
Markus Dierker on Invoxia Triby :: Ein starker Zwerg at 12:06
Volker Weber on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 11:28
Axel Borschbach on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 11:24
Maik Endler on Orientierung im iPad-Angebot at 09:34

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 06:01

visitors.gif

buy me coffee

Paypal vowe