Keep your cool about Meltdown and Spectre

by Volker Weber

Linus is furious:

Any speculative indirect calls in the kernel can be tricked to execute any kernel code, which may allow side channel attacks that can leak arbitrary kernel data.
Why is this all done without any configuration options?

A *competent* CPU engineer would fix this by making sure speculation doesn't happen across protection domains. Maybe even a L1 I$ that is keyed by CPL.

Now calm the f&ck down. Most of the people who write about this stuff don't know what is going on. They are just copying from what others have already written.

Let's be frank here. There are basically two problems: one is with general CPU architecture and one is a weakness specific to Intel. A weakness does not mean that you have an exploit. What software vendors are doing right now is to mitigate the risk that somebody is going to come up with an exploit that works on their platform. These mitigations do not fix the weakness.

What does it all mean for you? Somebody has to run code on your machine to execute the exploit. If you are a cloud service provider in the IaaS space, you should be very worried. And they are. If you are looking at your own personal device, not so much. Operating systems and browsers are being fixed, and they will need to be fixed for a long time coming.

Most importantly, do not rush.

The mitigations will break things that are working now. One example is anti-virus software. I already have a first fix on my Windows 10 Surface Pro because there is no unsupported software on this machine, Microsoft requires AV vendors to write a registry key before they will offer this fix to your machine.

Do practice safer computing though. Don't install stuff from dubious sources.

Comments

You‘re simply the best ... Happy new year, Volker!

Stephan Perthes, 2018-01-05 14:40

An article explaining this topic and why Raspberry Pi is immune:
https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/why-raspberry-pi-isnt-vulnerable-to-spectre-or-meltdown/

Karsten Lehmann, 2018-01-05 23:53

Wie schon des öfteren: Danke Volker.
Deine Kommentare bringen es immer wieder auf den Punkt und holen einen auf den Boden zurück.
Im konkreten Fall wird wieder einmal eine Sau von vielen Unwissenden durchs Dorf getrieben. Bei nüchterner Betrachtung ist sehr viel davon deutlich zu relativieren.

W.

Werner Hofer, 2018-01-06 00:23

Danke Karsten ;)

Mariano Kamp, 2018-01-06 09:09

Heise ist mir bislang nicht als Journal zum Sau-durchs-Dorf-treiben aufgefallen.

Habt ihr alle Javascript abgeschaltet? Benutzer ihr keine Browser?

Zitat Stiller im heutigen Heise Hintergrundartikel: "
nicht nur Clouds und Server sind betroffen, sondern auch die PCs zuhause, insbesondere gibt es auch Angriffsmöglichkeiten via Browser, "

Na dann, lasst euch ruhig Zeit mit den Updates...

Lucius Bobikiewicz, 2018-01-08 07:04

Post a comment

Store next two fields in a cookie for you?




Use your full name and a working email address. Unless you want your comment to be removed. No kidding.

Recent comments

Volker Weber on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 20:22
Henning Heinz on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 20:12
Christian Tillmanns on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 18:55
Volker Weber on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 16:26
Nina Wittich on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 16:04
Volker Weber on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 15:36
Henning Heinz on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 15:30
Volker Weber on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 15:09
Karsten Lehmann on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 14:57
Volker Weber on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 14:39
Karsten Lehmann on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 14:35
Markus Dierker on Beating IBM is a walk in the park at 14:35
Carsten Lührmann on #domino2025 Online Forum at 13:17
Volker Weber on #domino2025 Online Forum at 10:05
sean cull on #domino2025 Online Forum at 08:00
Johannes Matzke on Fataler Konstruktionsfehler im besonderen elektronischen Anwaltspostfach at 07:39
Nils Michael Becker on Fataler Konstruktionsfehler im besonderen elektronischen Anwaltspostfach at 01:03
Alexander Kluge on #domino2025 Online Forum at 22:09
Markus Dierker on #domino2025 Online Forum at 21:00
Ben Langhinrichs on #domino2025 Online Forum at 20:29
Volker Weber on #domino2025 Online Forum at 19:15
Christian Tillmanns on #domino2025 Online Forum at 19:11
Volker Weber on #domino2025 Online Forum at 17:12
Andrew Manby on #domino2025 Online Forum at 17:07
Volker Weber on #domino2025 Online Forum at 16:55

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter

Local time is 20:52

visitors.gif