Slack vs Watson Workspace Load Times

by Volker Weber

They are both built using Electron. I have no idea what IBM is doing here.

Update: Not as terrible on the Mac as on Windows. So this may be fixable. Version 1.0.53 on both Mac and Windows.

Comments

Never mind, Volker. Probably IBM doesn't have, either ;)

Hubert Stettner, 2018-03-05

Try using Slack Enterprise (which consumes around 2GB of RAM - I wonder why people aren't complaining about RAM usage) - it takes as long if not longer to load and consumes 3-4 times more RAM than Watson Workspace.

Daniel Silva, 2018-03-05

The absolute overkill is using Franz messenger that instantiates a single Electron client per service - a nightmare. I am using it though just to save some task buttons. In general I don't get the WW idea so far. No benefits for me and the Watson services are the ones I couldn't care less. Persistent chats are a mess, with or without AI.

Oliver Busse, 2018-03-05

Daniel, I wasn't concerned about memory usage. Just checked task manager and Slack was at 250 MB and Watson Workspace at 490 MB. Did not make much difference to me since the machine has 16 GB of RAM.

I was also told that Watson Workspace loads faster than Slack on the Mac. Checked that as well and installed the same version. It is indeed different there. Watson Workspace loads in a reasonable time on Mac. Slack spends a bit of time connecting to the service first so the space is already updated when you see it. It's a race with no clear winner. About five seconds for both.

So wtf is going on with the Watson Workspace Client on Windows? Are all IBM developers on Macs and don't see the issue?

Oliver, I have a couple of persistant chats and they work for me. However, it's not easy to convince old time mail users there is a benefit in not sending everything through mail.

Volker Weber, 2018-03-05

Sure I prefer persistent chats over mail but chats tend to have more "noise" when I return after a few days. My inbox though is cleaned up in less time than I am able to gather all the channels - especially when you have to harvest several of them.

Oliver Busse, 2018-03-05

I probably would not try to catch up with chat after a few days. Some things take care of themselves, especially in realtime conversations.

But since you mention it, this seems to be one of the things that Watson Workspace wants to solve. I just can't get it to do that in a reasonable way. OTOH it is missing so many other things ...

Volker Weber, 2018-03-05

Exactly but from my experience it only does properly reduce clutter when the conversation is in English so far. It has a simple and working API / interface for own stuff though.

Oliver Busse, 2018-03-05

I have seen some examples of bot-like behaviours, but nothing convincing so far. Reminds me of "Mail that understands me". https://youtu.be/JSLY1JXLKO0 And then it did not take the world by storm.

Volker Weber, 2018-03-05

One way WW could be of tremendous use: listen to the conversations and figure out what looks like a consensus or decision and what it was about. Then present that in a special view.
Tracking decisions is a quite tricky unsolved business issue

Stephan H. Wissel, 2018-03-06

Recent comments

Paul T Calhoun on Drawing on the iPad Pro 12.9 at 15:45
Dennis Frank on Drawing on the iPad Pro 12.9 at 12:06
Sami Bahri on Traktor KONTROL S4 MK3 at 10:42
Ragnar Schierholz on Last-Minute-Geschenk :: udoq-Qi-Lader at 08:01
Thomas Mendorf on Traktor KONTROL S4 MK3 at 02:08
Volker Weber on Kleines Update zu ginlo at 00:02
Christopher Schmidt on Kleines Update zu ginlo at 23:53
Jan Van Puyvelde on Tagesangebote heute at 23:32
Kai Schmalenbach on Traktor KONTROL S4 MK3 at 21:23
Marco Schirmer on Traktor KONTROL S4 MK3 at 19:34
Volker Weber on An fremdem USB-Port sicher laden at 17:34
Christoph Jung on An fremdem USB-Port sicher laden at 17:28
Volker Weber on Unfallfolgen :: Ab jetzt geht es bergauf at 17:16
Felix Kluge on Unfallfolgen :: Ab jetzt geht es bergauf at 16:17
Kai Schmalenbach on Android Updates :: Nokia macht weiter alles richtig at 15:45
Adrian Woizik on Traktor KONTROL S4 MK3 at 12:21
Volker Weber on An fremdem USB-Port sicher laden at 10:50
Norbert Tretkowski on An fremdem USB-Port sicher laden at 10:47
Volker Weber on Unfallfolgen :: Ab jetzt geht es bergauf at 10:20
Andreas Braukmann on Kleines Update zu ginlo at 10:16
Christoph Jung on An fremdem USB-Port sicher laden at 09:44
Stephan H. Wissel on Unfallfolgen :: Ab jetzt geht es bergauf at 08:35
Volker Weber on Kleines Update zu ginlo at 01:17
Andreas Braukmann on Kleines Update zu ginlo at 01:08
Volker Weber on An fremdem USB-Port sicher laden at 22:14

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 21:39

visitors.gif

buy me coffee