Apple HomePod vs Sonos Beam :: Ein unfairer Vergleich

by Volker Weber

IMG 3908

Max hat heute seinen Sonos Beam geliefert bekommen, und ich konnte es nicht erwarten, den auch mal zu hören. Ich hatte den Beam blind empfohlen, weil er aktuell die meisten Fähigkeiten aller Sonos Lautsprecher hat: Airplay 2, Alexa, HDMI ARC, HDMI CEC, Ethernet, WLAN und natürlich alle Musikdienste. Die Alternative waren 2x Sonos ONE, aber dort könnte man keinen Fernseher anschließen, wenn er das mal will. Da Max ein Apple-Nutzer ist, iPhone, iPad Pro, MacBook Pro, Apple TV, kam natürlich auch ein HomePod in Frage.

Um es kurz zu machen: der Beam bläst den HomePod schlicht an die Wand. Das hatte ich nicht erwartet, sonst hätte ich mir den Vergleich erspart. Transparenz, Lautstärke, Soundstage, alles kann der Beam besser. Die Musik verteilt sich gleichmäßig im Raum. Wie auch bei der Playbar und der Playbase klingt der Beam viel breiter als er ist.

IMG 3910

Nicht direkt erkennbar: die Oberfläche ist leicht konkav, ich vermute, damit man die LEDs beim Fernsehen nicht sieht.

Comments

I'm very interested in the dialogue mode of the beam for loved ones that suffer from hearing loss I'm hoping that mode might help them hear the TV better at volumes that aren't uncomfortable. I'll have to try it!

Jason Hook, 2018-07-20

I went for the Playbar in the end. The sound reproduction is better than the beam. I'm not at all bothered about voice control.

The speech enhancement mode does make a difference. Music becomes subdued and speech a bit more trebly. Having the sound projected toward you rather than projected off the wall behind the tv helps too.

The max volume of the playbar doesn't seem all that loud. The sub seems quite expensive.

I look forward to pairing it up with some Play:1s and see how it sounds then.

Jason Hook, 2018-07-25

The Sub is expensive und only really necessary for the deep bass often embedded in movies.

There is a second interesting setting beyond speech enhancement: Night mode. It compresses the sound. Loud parts become quieter, quiet parts become louder. This also helps people with hearing loss, since you can dial up the volume higher without disturbing explosions.

Volker Weber, 2018-07-25

Thank you for the reminder about Night Mode feature! I'll give it a go this evening.

I'd seen an advert for nuraphone headphones which can be configured for an individual's own hearing and emailed their tech support department asking about hearing loss. Apparently they haven't done any specific work or testing in this area but might in the future.

Thanks again!

Jason Hook, 2018-07-26

A Sonos Beam just entered or household last Saturday. Previously, my wife complained, that she had a hard time understanding dialogue in english TV series or movies because of the original sound-mix. Dubbed sound (i.e. german dialogue) tends to emphasize dialogue over sound effects or background music.

I am happy to report, the Sonos Beam fixed that problem for her. She is able to watch TV or movies on a significant lower volume level than before. On top of that, she and the kids love Alexa. ;-)

(and, of course, the Sonos Beam was bought at ueberall-musik.de)

Henning Grote, 2018-08-14

Kids love Alexa. Watch out for them ordering candy.

Volker Weber, 2018-08-14

Recent comments

Bernd Hofmann on Gestern in der Tagesschau at 05:31
Volker Weber on Orientierung im iPad-Angebot at 00:27
Volker Weber on Invoxia Triby :: First Impressions at 23:18
Kai Pahl on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 22:46
Chris Stahl on Invoxia Triby :: First Impressions at 22:40
Rafael Mayoral on Orientierung im iPad-Angebot at 21:50
Axel Koerv on Startschuss bei der 5G-Auktion: Spektrum für das Netz der Zukunft at 21:44
Christian Ott on Startschuss bei der 5G-Auktion: Spektrum für das Netz der Zukunft at 20:38
Volker Weber on Startschuss bei der 5G-Auktion: Spektrum für das Netz der Zukunft at 20:11
Felix Albrecht on Startschuss bei der 5G-Auktion: Spektrum für das Netz der Zukunft at 20:10
Roland Dressler on Orientierung im iPad-Angebot at 20:00
Volker Weber on Startschuss bei der 5G-Auktion: Spektrum für das Netz der Zukunft at 19:50
Kai Kramhöft on Startschuss bei der 5G-Auktion: Spektrum für das Netz der Zukunft at 19:04
Volker Weber on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 18:22
Reinhard Fellner on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 17:48
Volker Weber on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 17:10
Reinhard Fellner on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 16:59
Volker Weber on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 16:35
Reinhard Fellner on Now is a good time to buy a new iMac at 16:27
Volker Weber on Apple hat angerufen at 15:41
Axel Koerv on Apple hat angerufen at 15:40
Jan Tietze on Apple hat angerufen at 11:37
Maik Endler on Apple hat angerufen at 09:05
Jörg Hermann on Apple hat angerufen at 08:26
Johannes Matzke on Apple hat angerufen at 07:25

Ceci n'est pas un blog

I explain difficult concepts in simple ways. For free, and for money. Clue procurement and bullshit detection.

vowe

Contact
Publications
Stuff that works
Amazon Wish List
Frequently Asked Questions

rss feed  twitter  amazon

Local time is 06:05

visitors.gif

buy me coffee

Paypal vowe